Scheck Hillel students are recognized nationally and locally for having shown academic excellence, character, leadership in school and community, talent in the arts and superior athletic performance. Recognition programs include:
- National Merit® Scholarship Program
- National Hispanic Recognition Program
- Advanced Placement® (AP) Scholar Awards
- Jaime and Raquel Gilinski Hillel Ambassadors
- Miami Herald Silver Knight Awards
- Miami Herald All-Dade Athletic Awards
- Independent Schools of South Florida (ISSF) Star Awards
- Duke Talent Identification Program (TIP)
- College Book Awards